American Idol Kickoff Night (16)

Well...it's time to pick the TOP 12!!!

Guess who finally got voted off!

ANTONELLA BARBA!!!

And...

Jared Cotter

And...SURPRISINGLY...

Sabrina Sloan and Sundance Head

As Randy put it, AMERICA GOT IT WRONG!!!

Sabrina and Sundance can sing!
It is Sanjaya and Haley that can't! If anything, it should've been those two gone! And they better be gone next!